Monday, September 10, 2007

Fergies Potential Headache

After the last game against Sunderland, I think Sir Alex finds himself faced with a few potential selection headaches in the next few weeks. Not a bad problem to have, but in todays world of footballers with over pampered egos, I think it is going to take all of his famous man management powers to keep every one happy. But in saying that, he has never been one to rotate excessively, like say Benitez does, so this may even be a new challenge for him. He also has a few more superstars to deal with than Benitez, and that is said in earnest not as some sort of snipe at Liverpool. Both the rotation and 'best team' policies have their own merits and faults. Benitez has a lot of 'squad' players to pick from whereas Fergie has a lot of what would be considered automatic selections.

The first of these headaches is created by Louis Saha's return to fitness and the first team. It doesn't take an expert to work out that he is exactly the type of player that United were lacking and although a lot of doubts exist around his fitness, whenever he plays and gets a decent run of games, he has proved that he is a very good player. We have looked very flat up front, and although Tevez has tried hard, he clearly cannot play the role that Saha does. Even when Rooney comes back it will be very hard to leave Saha out, as he also thrives playing off of someone. If you think back to the worst United performances over the last few years, they have all come with Rooney playing up top on his own. When they are all available, it is going to be interesting to see what The Boss does.

But that dilemma is small compared to the one he has in midfield. Ronaldo and Scholes pretty much pick themselves, especially after last season, which leaves Carrick, Giggs, Nani, Anderson, Hargreaves and Fletcher to fill two spaces. In my opinion Hargeaves needs to play, as he looks to be exactly the kind of player we have been missing. Someone who can protect the back four and turn defence into attack in an instant. Giggs gets the nod too as he still delivers at a consistently high level and is one of the few people in the league who manages to clear the first defender from a deadball situation almost every time. He is also a Fergie stalwart and keeps defying his age. Nani has probably played a bigger role than initially expected and played relatively well at that, so he will be itching to keep his place. Anderson was in and around the Porto first team for a while, both domestically and in the Champions League, so will want to get on and impress too. Darren Fletcher is not exactly the type of player to set the world alight, but has recently proven to be quite capable when called upon. Fergie also seems to have a lot of faith in his potential and will not want to give up on him. So all of these will need to be kept happy.

The biggest loser in this sitiuation looks as though it is going to be Michael Carrick, probably too good to be on the bench, but not consistent enough to displace Scholes or Hargreaves, he may turn into a very expensive substitute or squad player. Even against Sunderland, he didn't looked too impressed to be on the bench and also has his England place to fight for. The midfield is where I think Fergie will need to apply most of his skills.

At the back it is pretty settled. Neville, Vidic, Ferdinand and Evra when they are all fit, with Brown and O' Shea for cover as they can both play anywhere across the back. I haven't mentioned Silvestre as I think he is a liability and will hopefully be on his way in January anyway.

It is going to be very intereseting to see how this problem is tackled, but I am sure it will result in another feather in Sir Alex's cap. It is after all a much better problem to have than last season and sets us up for an all out assault on the Champions League.

3 comments:

Andrew K said...

I Agree it will be a headache for SAF. I am optomistic about this year though and i do think we will be competing in all major competitions and this will make the selection choices easier as we will need fresh legs (as we did last season in the Champs v AC Milan). Excellent post bud.

Unknown said...

"But in saying that, he has never been one to rotate excessively, like say Benitez does, so this may even be a new challenge for him. He also has a few more superstars to deal with than Benitez, and that is said in earnest not as some sort of snipe at Liverpool."

Good post Neil, however i would like to disagree about your quote above. Although you said you are not taking a snipe at Liverpool, I do not believe your statement is completely accurate.


Reina
Van D Sar
Finnin Neville
Carra Ferdinand
Agger
Vidic
Riise Evra
Pennant Ronaldo
Mascherano Hargreves
Gerrard Scholes
Babbel
Giggs
Torres Rooney
Kuyt Saha

Subs (in no particular order)

Intanje Foster
Alonso
O' Shea
Sissoko Carrick
Benayoun Fletcher
Crouch Tevez
Vorinin Nani
Aurelio Anderson
Arbeloa
Park
Hyypia Silvestre
Kewell Brown
Leiva Eagles

I believe both 1st 11 are very close in quality. If we go into player to player discussion, united and liverpool fans could argue all day. I think it is just fair to say they are quite close in quality (note this is without been bias) .
However my arguement does not lie with the first 11:

"He also has a few more superstars to deal with than Benitez"
I believe Rafa has just as a big headache as SAF.

Neil Webster said...

Hey what's a scally doing on a United blog?

Ha Ha!! Just kidding Serg..... As far as quality goes I think there is very little in it, although the Ronaldo/Pennant match up is an exception.

But the superstar thing was not meant as a good thing for us, just that Fergie has a few more bigger egos to deal with, like Rooney, Ronaldo, Rio, Carrick, Giggs etc. With the exception of Giggs, I think the rest of them believe too much of their own press. The closest thing Liverpool have to that is Stevie G, but I would put him in with Scholes, not interested in being a "superstar" just playing the game he loves. Even Torres was not touted as a superstar when he arrived with many people thinking he would struggle(I was not one of them, the boy is class) The same would never happen if say Ronaldo moved to Spain...

So that's it, overall quality, very evenly matched,United ust have a few bigger egos. Which can be a cock up, just ask Real....